csen
No Easy Answers for Metro Atlanta’s Failure of Regional Planning

I get it. I know what you’re thinking. I grew up outside of DC and Boston. “How can 2 inches of snow shut down Atlanta?”

Before I got here, I thought that too. I wonder it every time there’s a run on the grocery stores before a storm, or when some other city cancels schools before a flake has even hit the ground.

And surely, the drivers play a part. I was out getting coffee around noon yesterday, just when things were starting to get bad traffic-wise (at the time there was, at most, a half inch of snow on the ground), and set out to drive my 2 miles home, a straight shot on a fairly major surface street. It took me around 30 minutes. Part of the reason was one of the drivers in front of me (with Tennessee plates) was going 5mph in a 35mph zone with no cars in front of them. But even with my car — 2013 model, 10,000 miles on it — I was skidding at times on the gentle incline of a street that hadn’t been treated with sand/salt/gravel at all.

My wife left work in Woodstock, a city 30-35 miles northwest of here, a little after noon yesterday, and took 3.5 hours to get home. Turns out, she was one of the lucky ones. Yes, Atlanta has many drivers who are inexperienced in the snow, but for a region that gets a storm (I know, I know “2 inches = storm”) like this at most once every few years, how is anyone ever supposed to be experienced in the snow? How do you think San Francisco would handle a couple inches of snow? Going north/south on Franklin or Gough, or east/west on Fell or Oak? How do you think the N-Judah out in Cole Valley or the Sunset would handle it? This is a metro area of 6 million people and it’s time to think beyond “those silly southern drivers.” It’s an issue and metro areas of 6 million people need to be prepared for anything.

Which leads into the blame game. Partisan politics time! Republicans want to blame government (a Democrat thing) or Atlanta (definitely a Democrat thing). Democrats want to blame the region’s dependence on cars (a Republican thing), the state government (Republicans), and many of the transplants from more liberal, urban places feel the same way you might about white, rural, southern drivers. All of this is true to some extent but none of it is helpful.

How much money do you set aside for snowstorms when they’re as infrequent as they are? Who will run the show? (cities/counties/state) How will preparedness work? You could train everyone today, and then if the next storm hits in 2020 everyone you’ve trained might have moved on to different jobs, with Atlanta having a new mayor and Georgia having a new governor.

Regionalism here is really hard. The population of this state has doubled in the past 40-45 years, and many of the older voters who control it still think of it as the way it was when they were growing up. The urban core of Atlanta is a minority participant in a state government controlled by rural and northern Atlanta exurban interests. The state government gives MARTA, Atlanta’s heavy rail transportation system, no money. There’s a lot of tough regional and racial history here which is shameful, but part of the inheritance we all have by being a part of this region. Demographics are evolving very quickly, but government moves more slowly. The city in which I live, Brookhaven, was incorporated in 2012. This is its first-ever snowstorm (again, 2 inches). It’s a fairly affluent, mostly white, urban small city. They were unprepared too.

The issue is that you have three layers of government — city, county, state — and none of them really trust the other. And why should they? Cobb County just “stole the Braves” from the city of Atlanta. Why would Atlanta cede transportation authority to a regional body when its history in dealing with the region/state has been to carve up Atlanta with highways and never embrace its transit system? Why would the region/state want to give more authority to Atlanta when many of the people in the region want nothing to do with the city of Atlanta unless it involves getting to work or a Braves game?

The region tried, in a very tough economy and political year (2012), to pass a comprehensive transportation bill, a T-SPLOST, funded by a sales tax. It wasn’t perfect, but it was an attempt to do something. The Sierra Club opposed it because it didn’t feature enough transit. The NAACP opposed it because it didn’t have enough contracts for minority businesses. The tea party opposed it because it was a tax. That’s politics in the 2010’s. You may snicker, but how good a job has any major city done with big transportation projects over the past 30 years?

The thing is, as anyone paying close attention will tell you, Atlanta’s finally moving in the right direction on this stuff. The Beltline build out underway and how it’s reshaping neighborhoods is a big deal. Downtown is finally getting some investment dollars, and we’ll see how useful it is, but it’s building a streetcar that will be up and running this year, with plans in the works for extensions. More and more counties in the region are tipping from red to purple/blue (Henry, Gwinnett, soon Cobb), which should help ease some of the racial and partisan tensions associated with regionalism. Most of the development dollars in a region driven by real estate are now flowing to urban, walkable projects. There are increasingly serious conversations about extending MARTA to the north and east. We’ve become one of the top 3 markets in the country for electric vehicle sales.

But clearly, there’s work to be done.

  1. shinybadguys reblogged this from commandersass
  2. omgwtfkk reblogged this from commandersass
  3. bella1893 reblogged this from commandersass
  4. commandersass reblogged this from csen
  5. artielu reblogged this from sweetestpiglet and added:
    A friend of mine came to visit me in SF. He is from Jersey, went to school in Philly and New York, and had never been...
  6. sweetestpiglet reblogged this from sulienapgwien
  7. sulienapgwien reblogged this from acciomjollnir
  8. amezri reblogged this from acciomjollnir
  9. acciomjollnir reblogged this from clickthefrog
  10. clickthefrog reblogged this from csen
  11. irresponsiblewiththehotsauce reblogged this from tamsindennis
  12. kpopnlock reblogged this from queenofattolia and added:
    Well said. I’ve been home from work for two days because of ice and snow. I don’t know how to drive in this weather and...
  13. vin-accardi reblogged this from sw0rdkind
  14. sw0rdkind reblogged this from nikitaduncan
  15. tamsindennis reblogged this from nikitaduncan and added:
    #if you’re laughing at Southern cities for cancelling things you’re an asshole#the real problem is that there are no...
  16. gryfndorgodess reblogged this from queenofattolia
  17. tameyourghosts-archive reblogged this from nikitaduncan and added:
    #THIS#110x this#if you’re laughing at Southern cities for cancelling things you’re an asshole#the real problem is that...
  18. nikitaduncan reblogged this from queenofattolia
  19. queenofattolia reblogged this from brainsister and added:
    This post is talking about Atlanta, but every bit of the first six paragraphs applies to my southern city and to most of...
  20. kaitechnolust reblogged this from csen and added:
    I moved to NY and haven’t had any problems with Atlanta traffic since. ;-)
  21. zzravizz reblogged this from csen
  22. brainsister reblogged this from csen and added:
    The above is getting a lot of attention because The Atlantic picked it up, but his whole Tumblr — which isn’t just about...
  23. bigdeelight reblogged this from csen and added:
    So you, Al Roker, and all of the opinions of people who don’t live, vote, or pay taxes in Georgia can kick a hard rock.
  24. johnnewsome reblogged this from csen